Lake Country Weather

Commenting login:
  • Log-in Edit profile
  • Register Logout


MHS Indian mascot heads to appeal - again

A wall in the Mukwonago High School gymnasium is one of the maintenance items given an extension for changing references to the Indian logo.

A wall in the Mukwonago High School gymnasium is one of the maintenance items given an extension for changing references to the Indian logo. Photo By Carol Spaeth-Bauer

Feb. 5, 2013

Mukwonago residents James Schoolcraft and Craig Vertz appealed a Wisconsin Court of Appeals decision to the Wisconsin Supreme Court on Friday in a continuing effort to challenge the constitutionality of a Wisconsin law barring some Indian nicknames and logos.

The petition filed by Attorney Sam Hall, from Crivello Carlson, claims that the Court of Appeals decision violates the supremacy clause in the United States Constitution. The petition argues that local taxpayers have standing to sue based on United States Supreme Court rulings. The petition also maintains that the law and its application violate taxpayers' due process and equal protection rights.

"It's a mix of federal and state law, and federal law should trump state law," Hall explained.

Legal wranglings

Waukesha County Circuit Court Judge Donald Hassin Jr. previously ruled that an official from the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI) had violated the constitutional rights of taxpayers in the Mukwonago Area School District. The circuit ruling stated that the DPI official who held the hearing, Paul Sherman, testified that he understood that the DPI supported the elimination of all Indian nicknames, regardless of how they were used in individual schools, and that Sherman "could see" how people might have concerns with impropriety because he was responsible for issuing the decision, and he was employed by the DPI.

The appeal points to at least one other pending lawsuit where Berlin High School challenged the constitutionality of the mascot law, and Berlin High School sits in a holding pattern awaiting the outcome of the Mukwonago case, Hall said.

On appeal, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals overturned the decision and ruled that Vertz and Schoolcraft did not have standing to bring the constitutional claims. The court held that Schoolcraft and Vertz should have attempted to become parties to the hearing by filing a request with Sherman or should have sought judicial review under state law rather than filing their federal civil rights lawsuit. Since the court ruled that Schoolcraft and Vertz did not have standing, the court did not consider whether the law violated the constitution.

While the attorney general has 15 days to oppose the appeal, Hall said the state Supreme Court has no deadline for addressing the issue. Hall did not want to speculate on the chances of the issue being picked up by the Supreme Court, but said he considered the chances are "better than average."

The district continues to wait, hoping for movement on legislation repealing the law. Superintendent Paul Strobel said legislators have told him the issue is not a priority for them.

This site uses Facebook comments to make it easier for you to contribute. If you see a comment you would like to flag for spam or abuse, click the "x" in the upper right of it. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use.


Special Sections



    Waterford 2015 Chamber                Menu Guide


Special sections archive


Weekend Happenings

Featured this week:  

Dousman FD Pancake Breakfast: 8 a.m.-12 p.m.  Oct. 11, Dousman Fire Department, 107 S. Main, Dousman. Also includes Flight for Life at 9 a.m.; room fire demonstration (live fire) at 10 a.m.; car extrication demonstration at 11 a.m.  plus balloon creations (8-10 a.m.),  bounce house.  Waukesha County Communications (9-1-1), Waukesha County Sheriff K-9, Waukesha County Mobile Command Unit, ATF vehicle.

Pancake Breakfast Fundraiser: 7 a.m. -12 p.m. Oct. 10, Oconomowoc Volunteer Fire Department, 212 Concord Road, Oconomowoc. Free will donations appreciated. Also includes fire trucks and displays, raffles, kids activities. Proceeds go toward the purchase of new emergency equipment.

Move Your Mutt for HAWS: 7 a.m. Oct. 10, Genesee Lake Road Town Park, Genesee Lake Road, Oconomowoc. Choose the 5K and bring your pet or run the 10K without your dog. There is also a one-mile walk. Raise $100 in pledges and race for free. Food and beverages available as well as vendor booths and adoptable pets from HAWS. $25 one-mile walk, $45 for 5K, 10K.


Tyke Hike: 10 a.m. Oct. 10, Lapham Peak State Park, W 329 N 846, Delafield. Please meet at the observation tower. Look for yellow ’Ice Age Trail Event’ signs. Tyke hikes are 60- to 90-minute slow-paced hikes promoting nature and family hiking in an outdoor educational setting. 


All weekend happenings